Chase Sapphire Reserve vs. Preferred: 7 Reasons Why the Reserve Is King

Susan Shain

Susan Shain | Versus

Jan 22, 2019 | Updated Feb 15, 2019

Choosing a travel rewards credit card? Then you’re probably facing the same Sapphire Preferred/Reserve conundrum that I once did.

I spent weeks asking myself: Chase Sapphire Reserve vs. Preferred? Which one is better?

Since I’ve now held both cards, I feel confident saying the Reserve is the better choice for frequent travelers. Here’s why.

Chase Sapphire Reserve vs. Chase Sapphire Preferred at a Glance

First off, note the Reserve and the Preferred both require good credit scores. (If you’re not there quite yet, check out these cards for every score.)

Here’s what else they have in common:

  • 50,000 Ultimate Rewards bonus points after spending $4,000 in the first 3 months after account opening
  • No foreign transaction fees
  • 1:1 point transfer to 12 travel partners

Chase Ultimate Rewards points are some of the most valuable in the business. Rather than being tied to a single airline or hotel chain, you can transfer these points at a 1:1 ratio to a dozen travel partners:

AIRLINE TRAVEL PARTNERS
Aer Lingus AerClub British Airways Executive Club Flying Blue AIR FRANCE KLM Iberia Plus JetBlue TrueBlue
Singapore Airlines KrisFlyer Southwest Airlines Rapid Rewards® United MileagePlus® Virgin Atlantic Flying Club
HOTEL TRAVEL PARTNERS
IHG® Rewards Club Marriott Rewards® World of Hyatt®

As for differences, the Reserve is allegedly harder to qualify for than the Preferred. 

That’s because it has a minimum credit limit of $10,000, while the Preferred has a minimum of $5,000. So if you don’t think you’ll be able to qualify for a $10,000 credit limit, due to your annual income or credit scores, the Preferred is probably a better bet.

Here are a few notable differences in their fees and rewards, too. (We’ll get into the rest of the perks below.)

Chase Sapphire Reserve Chase Sapphire Preferred
Annual Fee $450 $95 (waived the first year)
Rewards
  • 3X points per dollar on travel and dining*
  • 1X on everything else
  • 2X points per dollar on travel and dining
  • 1X on everything else
Point Value
  • 1.5 cents per point redeemed through the Chase Ultimate Rewards portal
  • Various point values through transfer partners
  • 1.25 cents per point redeemed through the Chase Ultimate Rewards portal
  • Various point values through transfer partners
Authorized User Fee $75 $0

*With the Sapphire Reserve, you’ll start earning 3X points on travel only after using your $300 annual travel credit, as described below.

7 Reasons Why the Chase Sapphire Reserve Beats the Preferred

The Chase Sapphire Reserve card or the Chase Sapphire Preferred card? In a perfect world, you could grab both.

But you can only hold one Sapphire card at a time — and can’t get a Sapphire card’s signup bonus if you’ve received another Sapphire card’s signup bonus in the past 48 months.

So, now that you’ve got the basics under your belt, here’s why I think the Reserve is a better choice for most people.

1. $300+ of Annual Travel Credits

I know, I know. The Reserve’s $450 annual fee sounds scary — and has made many people wonder: “Is the Chase Sapphire Reserve worth it?”

Here’s the thing: The Reserve’s net annual fee is more like $150, because the card offers a $300 annual travel credit that applies to a wide range of purchases, including transportation, hotels, and airfare.

Although you’ll pay the $450 annual fee as soon as you open the card, you’ll then notice statement credits popping up for the first $300 of travel purchases you make every year.

Spent $20 on parking? Chase will reimburse it. $150 on a hotel? Same thing.

Chase Sapphire Reserve travel credits

Some of my recent Chase Sapphire Reserve travel credits.

In essence, these credits bring the Reserve’s annual fee down to $150 — only $55 more than the Preferred.

After using up the full $300 travel credit every year, you’ll begin earning 3X points on travel purchases.

You’ll also receive a $100 application fee credit for Global Entry or TSA Pre✓ with the Reserve, which you can use once every four years. So if you’re not yet a member of either program, that’s another useful credit worth $25 per year.

Don’t normally make $300 in travel purchases a year? Then a travel rewards card might not be right for you. Consider a cash back, gas, or grocery store card instead — or a card co-branded with a major retailer like Amazon or Target.

2. 3X Points on Travel and Dining

Get this: The Chase Sapphire Reserve credit card offers a whopping 3X points per dollar on travel and dining worldwide. 

If you’re redeeming through the Ultimate Rewards portal for 1.5 cents per point, you’d be getting a 4.5% cash back equivalent in those categories. If you get more value through a point transfer, like 2 cents per point, you’d be getting a 6% cash back equivalent.

You’ll only find a travel rewards rate that good on premium credit cards like this, unless you’re talking about cash back cards with quarterly categories, or co-branded cards that earn a high rate with one chain — like the Hilton Honors American Express Card earning 6X points per dollar at Hilton.

Since much of my credit card spending goes toward Lyfts, plane tickets, hotels, and restaurants, this is a super valuable perk for me.

The Chase Sapphire Preferred still earns a good rewards rate: 2X points per dollar on travel and dining.

That gives you a cash back equivalent of 2.5% in those categories when redeeming through the Ultimate Rewards portal, at 1.25 cents per point. If you get a point transfer for 2 cents per point you’d be earning a 4% cash back equivalent instead.

2X might not seem like much less than 3X, but if you spend an average of $500 per month in these categories, that’s a difference of 12,000 versus 18,000 Ultimate Rewards points each year. Over the next five years, that’d add up to 30,000 extra points — enough for a roundtrip flight!

3. 50% Point Bonus

As mentioned above, another important thing to note is the Reserve’s points are actually worth more when redeemed through Chase’s Ultimate Rewards portal.

When redeemed for travel expenses like flights or hotel stays through Chase’s booking engine, each Reserve point is worth 1.5 cents. The Preferred card’s points are only worth 1.25 cents. That means you’re getting 20% more value per point with the Reserve than the Preferred.

Although we’d recommend transferring your points directly to an airline or hotel to get the most value, this is a solid perk for people who prefer to book through Chase.

Imagine the 50,000 points you can earn through the introductory bonus of either the Preferred or Reserve. When redeeming through Ultimate Rewards, 50,000 points would yield $750 worth of travel for Reserve cardholders, as opposed to $625 for Preferred cardholders.

4. Priority Pass Airport Lounge Access

This was the reason I jumped ship to the Chase Sapphire Reserve: It comes with a Priority Pass Select membership. While this isn’t the best airport lounge membership card around, it is a fabulous perk if you don’t have lounge access through other cards or elite statuses.

Priority Pass has more than 1,200 airport lounges in 143 countries. At these lounges, you’ll find free food, WiFi, and drinks, making long layovers much more pleasant.

The Priority Pass perks aren’t limited to lounge access, either: Membership also gets you dining credits at select airport restaurants.

In the past, I’ve used my Priority Pass card to get a $30 credit at P.F. Chang’s in LAX (plus $30 for my guest!) and $28 at Capers Cafe in PDX. All I had to pay was the tip. Free restaurant meals, just for having a credit card? Count me in!

$60 of free food at P.F. Chang's, all thanks to the Chase Sapphire Reserve

$60 of free food and drink at P.F. Chang’s, all thanks to the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

Certain lounges restrict Priority Pass access when they’re busy. A few times, I’ve walked to a lounge to discover it wasn’t accepting Priority Pass users for another few hours. If premium lounge access is your main credit card goal, I recommend The Platinum Card® from American Express (Review) instead, which has the best lounge access of any credit card (along with the business version of that card).

5. Better Benefits for Drivers

Back when I had the Chase Sapphire Preferred, I had to use its rental car insurance after being rear-ended by a bus in Iceland. The coverage was great — and while I haven’t had to test the Reserve’s car rental coverage yet (knock on wood!), it’s even better.

Both of these Sapphire cards provide “Primary” Car Rental Insurance, which means that, if you’re in an accident, you can send the bill directly to Chase. (The vast majority of other cards offer “secondary” insurance, which means you’ll need to bill your regular car insurance first, potentially increasing your premium.)

The biggest difference is the Reserve covers “expensive and exotic cars,” and offers reimbursement of up to $75,000. The Preferred will only cover “up to the actual cash value of the vehicle as it was originally manufactured,” according to that card’s Guide to Benefits.

In terms of Roadside Assistance, the Reserve shines, too: Whereas the Preferred charges a fee for each service call, the Reserve covers up to $50 per incident, up to four times per year. 

6. Generous Travel Insurance

Earlier this year, due to a cascade of canceled flights, I got stuck at the Greenville-Spartanburg (GSP) airport for eight hours. It was about as exciting as it sounds.

Although GSP didn’t have a Priority Pass lounge, I still managed to avoid paying for expensive airport food. That’s because the Reserve card offers up to $500 per ticket of Trip Delay Insurance on delays of six hours or more (or those which require an overnight stay).

That covers purchases like “meals, lodging, toiletries, medication and other personal use items,” according to the Sapphire Reserve’s Guide to Benefits.

Email from Chase Sapphire Reserve card benefit services

Victory! Chase Sapphire Reserve approves my trip delay reimbursement.

The Preferred offers $500 of trip delay coverage, too, but only on delays of 12 hours or more (or that require an overnight stay). On that day in GSP, I wouldn’t have been eligible for reimbursement with the Preferred.

That said, both cards offer solid travel coverage, including:

  • Trip Cancellation and Interruption Insurance of up to $10,000 per covered trip
  • Baggage Delay Insurance of up to $100 per day for five days
  • Lost Luggage Reimbursement of up to $3,000 per person (up to $500 per person for jewelry, watches, cameras, video recorders, and other electronic equipment)
  • Travel Accident Insurance of $100,000 for 24-hour loss of life benefit, and $500,000 (Preferred) or $1 million (Reserve) for common carrier loss of life

The Reserve offers a few additional health benefits, too: up to $100,000 in Emergency Evacuation Coverage and up to $2,500 in emergency medical expenses, including $75 per day (for up to five days) for a hotel room if a doctor says you can’t travel right away.

7. Expanded Purchase and Return Protection

Let’s say you buy a new laptop on your credit card, and the next week it gets stolen. While that royally sucks, it’ll suck a little less with the Sapphire cards.

As long as you charged the item to your card, you’ll get Purchase Protection for 120 days. 

  • The Preferred card will “replace, repair, or reimburse you up to a maximum” of $500 per claim, and $50,000 per account.
  • The Reserve card will “replace, repair, or reimburse you up to a maximum” of $10,000 per claim, and $50,000 per year.

The Reserve also offers Return Protection, which reimburses you if you’re dissatisfied with a purchase you made — and the merchant won’t accept your return.

Within 90 days of the purchase (which must be made on the card), Chase will reimburse you up to $500 per item, for a maximum of $1,000 per year. The item must be in “like-new/good working condition.” The Preferred discontinued return protection in August 2018.

Chase Sapphire Reserve vs. Preferred: Why the Reserve Wins

Should you upgrade your Chase Sapphire Preferred to the Reserve? That’s up to you. But I made that move several years ago — and have never looked back.

The biggest roadblock — the $450 annual fee — is offset by the $300 annual travel credit and $100 Global Entry or TSA Pre✓ application fee credit.

You’ll also be able to earn 1X more point per dollar on travel and dining, redeem points for 20% more value through Chase’s travel portal, and take advantage of the wealth of perks like lounge access and travel insurance.

In my opinion, the only reason you might opt for the Preferred is if your credit isn’t quite where it needs to be for the Reserve. Or if you don’t think you’ll use the entire $300 annual travel credit.

But, for most frequent travelers, the Reserve is simply one of the best credit cards around.

Want to take a deeper dive into these cards? Read our comprehensive reviews:

Still wondering about your other options? See our picks for the Best Travel Reward Credit Cards.
Was this helpful?

The responses below are not provided or commissioned by bank advertisers. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by bank advertisers. It is not the bank advertisers' responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

The Insider

Susan Shain
How to Set a Travel Notice for Your Credit Cards (Including Chase)
Susan Shain | Feb 21, 2019

Getting ready for a trip? Here's how to set a travel notice for credit cards from eight issuers, including step-by-step directions for Chase travel notices.

Read More
Susan Shain
How to Get TSA PreCheck Free: Try These 6 Credit Cards
Susan Shain | Feb 11, 2019

Want to get TSA PreCheck free? Here are six great credit cards that pay for your application fee — plus why you might want to opt for Global Entry instead.

Read More
Michelle Black
What Is a Credit Limit and How Does It Affect Your Credit Scores?
Michelle Black | Feb 08, 2019

Understanding how credit limits work and how they can impact your credit scores is an important part of being a smart credit card user.

Read More